A free expansion for The Binding of Isaac has sparked a major backlash on PC and consoles following the discovery of AI-generated assets. The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ recently launched on PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X/S, and Switch 2 alongside a companion update on Steam. The release included a marketing stunt designed to compete with Rockstar Games' Grand Theft Auto 6 by adding a special crime-themed daily run.

Quick Facts

  • Update: The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ free update
  • Platforms: PC (Steam), PS5, Xbox Series X/S, Switch 2
  • Core Issue: Discovery of Suno AI-generated music tracks in the secret Vice City mode
  • Steam User Rating: Dropped to 9 percent positive following user review bombing

The GTA-Inspired Mode and Suno AI Discovery

Players who entered the seed “V1CE BSMT” into the roguelike or completed the daily run gained access to a special mode featuring special weapons, vehicular themes, and custom music. However, Reddit user ShweetsStuff published a detailed breakdown alleging that 14 music tracks featured in the run were created using Suno, an AI-based music generation tool.

According to the findings, several audio files contained explicit Suno metadata in their file comments, including creation timestamps and unique identifiers. Other files had their comments scrubbed, pointing to later edits before export. Steam store guidelines explicitly require developers to disclose content generated with the help of AI, a disclosure that was absent from the expansion's store page.

Developer and Publisher Response

The implementation drew sharp criticism from fans on the game's subreddit, who targeted publisher and co-developer Nicalis over quality control concerns, lingering bugs, and latency issues. The backlash drove the expansion's Steam user rating down to an abysmal 9 percent positive.

Game creator Edmund McMillen stated publicly that he had no prior knowledge of the generated music's inclusion in the daily run. Following the outcry, Nicalis pushed out an emergency update to strip the AI-generated tracks from the game, though the publisher has not yet explained how the audio files made it into the release or taken direct responsibility for their use.